How to Answer “Strengths?” and “Weaknesses?” in a Case Interview

Last Updated on January 29, 2024

Navigating the strengths and weaknesses questions in top-tier consulting interviews like those at McKinsey, BCG, and Bain is crucial for leaving a lasting impression. These questions, often featured in the fit interview segment, provide a platform to showcase your self-awareness, relevance to the consulting role, and alignment with the firm’s culture.

This article aims to equip you with the insights and strategies needed to articulate your strengths and weaknesses in a manner that resonates with the interviewers, ensuring you stand out in your consulting interview journey. Whether you are interviewing with firms that focus on a more traditional fit interview format or McKinsey with its unique Personal Experience Interview, understanding how to tailor and deliver your responses is key to success.

Structured Approach to Answering Strengths and Weaknesses Questions

In consulting interviews, structuring your responses to the strengths and weaknesses questions can significantly enhance their clarity and impact. Here’s a suggested approach:

Addressing Your Greatest Strength:

1. Begin with a High-Level Summary: Start with a concise statement summarizing your key strength.
2. Illustrate with an Example: Provide a specific instance or scenario where you demonstrated this strength effectively.
3. Impact of Your Strength: Explain how this strength has positively influenced your work or team outcomes.
4. Relate to Consulting: Tie your strength to relevant consulting skills and the value you would bring to the firm.

Addressing Your Greatest Weakness:

1. Start with a Summary: Open with a brief acknowledgment of a specific weakness.
2. Provide Context with an Example: Share a situation that highlighted this weakness, making your acknowledgment tangible.
3. Detail Improvement Steps: Discuss the specific actions you’ve taken to address and work on this weakness.
4. Showcase the Results: Highlight tangible outcomes or progress resulting from your efforts to improve.
5. Reflect on Ongoing Development: Conclude by reflecting on what you’ve learned from this process and areas you’re continuing to develop.

By using this structure, you not only present a well-thought-out response but also demonstrate key consulting traits like self-awareness, analytical thinking, and a commitment to personal growth. This structured approach will set your answers apart, making them more memorable and effective.

Answering “What Are Your Strengths?”

This is arguably the easier question to answer in a job interview as everyone likes to talk about their strengths and better qualities.

When asked about your strengths, it is important to be honest and to provide specific examples to support your claims. You should try to focus on strengths that are relevant to the job you are applying for and that demonstrate your ability to perform well in the role. Here are some tips for answering this question:

1. Identify your top strengths: Think about your skills, experiences, and accomplishments, and consider which ones you feel are your strongest. All of these need to be relevant for the job as a consultant! If you are curious to understand what consulting firms are looking for in their applicants, read here.
2. Provide specific examples: Don’t just list your strengths; give specific examples of times when you have demonstrated these strengths in the past. You need proof of your character trait, ideally in the form of a credible story.
3. Keep it relevant: Choose strengths that are relevant to the job you are applying for. For example, if you are applying for an entry-level generalist consulting role with McKinsey, a strength like “excellent marketing know-how” is not particularly relevant. Rather, discuss your excellent problem-solving skills, for instance.
4. Avoid cliches: Avoid using cliches or overused strengths, such as “hardworking” or “motivated.” Instead, try to be specific and unique.
5. Stay positive: Keep your answer positive and focused on your strengths, rather than dwelling on weaknesses or areas for improvement.

The Top 10 Strengths to List in Consulting Interviews

In a consulting interview, choosing strengths that align with the demands and values of the consulting industry is crucial. Here are ten strengths that are highly valued and can make a strong impact:

1. Analytical Skills: Demonstrating the ability to analyze complex data and draw meaningful insights is key in consulting.
2. Problem-Solving Abilities and Curiosity: Showcasing your talent for identifying issues and developing effective solutions is essential.
3. Adaptability: Being able to adjust quickly to new challenges and changing environments is a critical trait in the dynamic world of consulting.
4. Strong Communication Skills: Both verbal and written communication skills are fundamental for effectively conveying ideas to clients and team members.
5. Leadership: Highlighting your ability to lead and motivate teams, especially in challenging project environments, can be a significant strength.
6. Teamwork and Collaboration: Consulting often involves working in diverse teams, so the ability to collaborate effectively is highly valued.
7. Work Ethic and Resilience: Demonstrating a strong commitment to your work and resilience in the face of obstacles is important in this high-pressure field.
8. Creativity and Innovation: The ability to think creatively and offer innovative solutions is highly prized in consulting.
9. Client Management Skills: If you have experience, showing your ability to manage client relationships and expectations is a great strength.
10. Attention to Detail: The capacity to pay attention to the finer details of a project or data set, ensuring accuracy and quality, is crucial.

In your response, it’s beneficial to not just list these strengths but also provide specific examples or experiences where you’ve effectively utilized them. This approach demonstrates not only your self-awareness but also the practical application of your skills.

Common Mistakes in Answering “What’s Your Greatest Strength?” in Consulting Interviews

When highlighting strengths to consulting firms, avoid the following.

1. Being Vague or Generic: Offering broad or non-specific strengths like “I’m a hard worker” or “I’m a good communicator” can make your response forgettable. Instead, provide unique strengths that set you apart and are directly relevant to consulting.
2. Lack of Relevant Examples: Simply stating a strength without backing it up with concrete examples or experiences diminishes its impact. Share specific situations or achievements that clearly demonstrate how your strength has been beneficial in a professional context.
3. Overstating or Exaggerating: Claiming strengths that are exaggerated or not supported by your experience can come across as dishonest or egotistical. Be realistic and grounded in your self-assessment.
4. Ignoring the Firm’s Values: Failing to align your strengths with the consulting firm’s values or culture can be a missed opportunity. Highlight strengths that resonate with the firm’s ethos and the demands of the consulting role.
5. Not Showing Self-Awareness: Discussing your strengths without acknowledging any room for growth can suggest a lack of self-awareness. It’s beneficial to mention how you continue to develop and refine your strengths.

In your response, the goal is to be specific, authentic, and self-aware, showcasing how your unique strengths make you a valuable candidate for the consulting role. Tailoring these strengths to align with the consulting firm’s specific needs and culture can significantly enhance the effectiveness of your answer.

Answering “What Are Your Weaknesses?”

It is common for consulting interviews to include questions about your weaknesses. Some firms such as BCG focus more on this compared to others. It is important to approach this question carefully and to avoid simply listing negative qualities or dwelling on your weaknesses. Rather, approach it, keeping these 4 things in mind:

1. Be honest: It is important to be honest when discussing your weaknesses, but try to choose ones that are not crucial to the job you are applying for. Do not say that you are bad at dealing with difficult people (which is a crucial skill for any newly-minted consultant)
2. Focus on areas for improvement: Rather than listing weaknesses that you have no intention of changing, focus on areas where you are actively working to improve. For instance, discuss that this weakness was an issue in the past, however, since you have been actively working on it, it is no longer a problem.
3. Turn a weakness into a strength: If possible, try to reframe a weakness as a strength. For example, if you tend to be a perfectionist, you could frame this as a strength by saying that you have a strong attention to detail and a commitment to quality (which sometimes takes more time, which is the negative/weakness).
4. Stay positive: Keep your answer positive and focused on your efforts to improve, rather than dwelling on your weaknesses or areas for improvement.

The Top 10 Weaknesses to List in Consulting Interviews

When discussing weaknesses in a consulting interview, it’s important to choose ones that are genuine but not detrimental to the core competencies required for the role. Here are ten weaknesses that, if presented thoughtfully and with a plan for improvement, can be suitable for such interviews:

1. Public Speaking: If presenting in front of large groups is challenging for you, this is a common weakness that can be improved with practice.
2. Overcommitting: Taking on too many tasks and struggling with delegation or saying no, which can lead to burnout.
3. Hesitancy in Decision-Making: A tendency to be cautious or indecisive when faced with complex decisions, especially under tight deadlines, which can impact efficiency. This weakness, however, shows careful consideration of options and outcomes.
4. Impatience: A tendency to be impatient with processes or results, especially in fast-paced environments.
5. Self-Criticism: Being overly critical of your own work, which shows high standards but can also hinder confidence.
6. Time Management: Struggling with managing time effectively, especially under pressure, is a common issue.
7. Difficulty with Work-Life Balance: Tendency to prioritize work over personal time, which can affect overall well-being.
8. Reluctance to Ask for Help: Hesitation to seek assistance or clarification when needed.
9. Handling Feedback: Being sensitive to criticism or taking time to adapt to feedback, though it shows a desire to improve.
10. Adapting to Change: Initial resistance or discomfort with rapid changes, common in dynamic industries.

When presenting these weaknesses, frame them in a way that shows your awareness and the proactive steps you are taking to address them. This demonstrates your ability to self-reflect, learn, and grow – qualities highly valued in consulting.

Common Mistakes in Answering “What’s Your Greatest Weakness?” in Consulting Interviews

When presenting weaknesses in interviews, avoid the following mistakes.

1. Avoiding the Question: Claiming you can’t identify any weaknesses suggests a lack of self-awareness. Acknowledge that everyone has areas to improve, especially in a dynamic field like consulting.
2. Disguising Strengths as Weaknesses: Avoid cliché responses like “I work too hard” or “I’m a perfectionist.” Such answers can come across as insincere and may indicate an unwillingness to be open and vulnerable about actual areas for improvement.
3. Revealing a Critical Weakness: Sharing a weakness that’s a potential deal-breaker, like poor teamwork skills or a lack of focus, can be damaging to your candidacy. Instead, choose a mild weakness that doesn’t conflict with the core requirements of a consulting role.
4. Lack of Sincerity in Your Response: Your delivery matters as much as the content. Ensure your response is expressed with genuine emotion and sincerity. A monotone, dispassionate answer might seem unconvincing and can undermine the authenticity of your response.

When discussing weaknesses, the key is to be honest yet tactful, showing that you’re aware of and actively working on your improvement areas. This approach demonstrates both self-awareness and a commitment to personal development, which are highly valued in consulting.

Strategies to Secure Job Offers from Top Consulting Firms like McKinsey, BCG, and Bain

As former McKinsey consultants and interview experts, we have specialized in getting our candidates an offer at MBB firms. We can help you by

• tailoring your resume and cover letter to meet MBB’s standards
• showing you how to pass the different online assessments and tests for McKinsey, BCG, and Bain
• showing you how to ace McKinsey interviews and the PEI with our video academy
• coaching you in our 1-on-1 sessions to become an excellent case solver and impress with your fit answers (90% success rate after 5 sessions)
• preparing your math to be bulletproof for every MBB case interview
• helping you structure creative and complex MBB cases
• teaching you how to interpret MBB charts and exhibits
• providing you with cheat sheets and overviews for 27 industries.

Reach out to us if you have any questions! We are happy to help and offer a tailored program to help you break into MBB.

To improve your skills in all areas of the interview, check out our targeted offers below.