Ace the McKinsey Phone Interview: Tips & Insights

Last Updated on November 21, 2024

The McKinsey phone interview is a recruiting device that is employed in various offices across the globe or used for very specific roles. It is a crucial step for many candidates eager to kick off their McKinsey careers.

Currently, there are two types of phone interviews McKinsey is conducting,

• the phone case interview
• the phone personal fit interview

In this article, I want to shed some light on both and tell you what to expect and how to prepare for each.

Understanding the McKinsey Phone Interview

The McKinsey phone interview is an integral step in the journey towards a career at one of the world’s leading consulting firms. Designed as a preliminary screening tool for certain offices, it sets the stage for candidates, offering a unique insight into the McKinsey approach to problem-solving and strategic thinking.

Typically lasting about 30 minutes, these interviews are often the first direct interaction candidates have with the firm and play a pivotal role in determining their potential for success in subsequent interview rounds.

The importance of the McKinsey phone interview cannot be overstated. It serves multiple critical purposes: firstly, it is a gatekeeper, filtering candidates based on key competencies and skills essential for a consultant at McKinsey. Secondly, it offers candidates a glimpse into the kind of thinking and analysis expected at McKinsey, preparing them for the depth and style of future interviews.

Moreover, the McKinsey phone assessment is not just about assessing technical proficiency; it’s also a test of how candidates handle pressure, think on their feet, and communicate complex ideas succinctly – all crucial qualities for a consultant.

The phone interview frequently serves a dual purpose, where HR not only evaluates candidates but also discusses subsequent steps and logistical details for upcoming interviews.

Overview of Potential Different Interview Components

The McKinsey phone interview typically encompasses either a case interview or a personal fit interview.

1. The Case Interview: Candidates are presented with a business problem and are evaluated on their ability to analyze, structure, and solve it logically. The case interview reflects real-world business scenarios and tests a wide range of skills from quantitative analysis to strategic thinking and creativity. It’s not just about finding the right answer but demonstrating a clear, structured approach to problem-solving.
2. The Personal Fit Interview: Though less emphasized in the phone interview compared to in-person interviews, the personal fit component is still essential. This part focuses on a candidate’s motivations, values, and alignment with McKinsey’s culture. Questions may revolve around past experiences, challenges faced, and key achievements. It’s an opportunity for the interviewer to gauge the candidate’s interpersonal skills, adaptability, and potential to thrive in McKinsey’s fast-paced, collaborative environment.

In summary, the McKinsey phone interview is a multifaceted evaluation tool, testing either analytical prowess or personal attributes.

Not all offices use the phone interview as a screening device. If your recruiting contact invites you to a phone screening, ask them to clarify what the topic of discussion will be, case or fit? You want to come prepared.

The McKinsey Phone Case Interview

The first type, known as the phone case interview, is commonly conducted by an HR representative or a firm alumnus, contrasting with in-person cases typically handled by consultants. This interview format, lasting about 30 minutes with a brief intro, mirrors a condensed McKinsey case study, encompassing standard question categories.

During these screenings, the interviewer, either from HR or an alumnus, records your responses in writing. These recorded responses, along with their observations, are then forwarded to a consultant who determines if you should advance to the next interview stage.”

In this McKinsey interview you will typically have to answer three different questions types – broadly speaking:

• Structuring (includes Brainstorming)
• Exhibit Interpretation (less likely to appear)
• Math

While most consulting firms use a candidate-led case interview format, McKinsey is known for its interviewer-led style. In this approach, the interviewer guides the conversation, presenting information and directing the discussion, while the candidate responds to specific questions and scenarios.

Now for Structure and Exhibit Interpretation, there is no right or wrong answer. Some answers are better than others because they are

• deep
• broad
• insightful
• hypothesis-driven
• follow a strong communication (MECE, top-down, signposted)

That being said, there is no 100% that you can reach or a one-and-only solution/ answer. Your answers must display the characteristics specified above and are supported well with arguments.

As for Math questions, usually, there are correct answers (not always 100% the same since some candidates simplify or round differently – which is ok), and others that are wrong, either due to the

• calculation approach
• calculation itself

Now, for the interviewer, the overall picture counts. Mistakes in one area need to be balanced by a strong performance in other areas. McKinsey wants to see spikes in performance in certain areas and a good enough performance in other areas.

The most common example I see almost every day: You can be strong in structure and exhibit, yet make a small mistake in the math section – overall as you might consider 80% – and still pass on to the next round.

McKinsey Interview Video Academy

Rated 4.98 out of 5 based on 57 customer ratings

(57 customer reviews)

$179.00 Original price was: $179.00.$99.00Current price is: $99.00.

Look behind the curtains and understand how to ace McKinsey Case and Personal Experience Interviews with our 40-part video academy. Curated by former McKinsey consultants and interviewers with the best track record in the industry.

Read more

Add to cart

What Questions Are Asked?

In a case interview as part of the McKinsey phone assessment, questions typically revolve around a case study simulating a real business problem. The interviewer may start with a general prompt, followed by a structuring question like, “What factors would you look at to investigate the decrease in customer satisfaction?”

These questions aim to evaluate how a candidate approaches complex business scenarios.

What Skills Are Assessed?

The assessments in a McKinsey phone case are designed to gauge a range of skills and attributes, for instance:

1. Logical and Structured Thinking: Candidates must demonstrate their ability to logically structure their thoughts and break down complex problems into manageable parts.
2. Analytical Problem Solving: This involves the ability to analyze data, interpret information, and derive insightful conclusions to propose practical solutions to the case problem.
3. Business Acumen: Candidates are assessed on their understanding of basic business principles and the ability to apply this knowledge in various scenarios.
4. Communication Skills: Effective communication is key. Candidates must articulate their thoughts clearly and concisely, ensuring their reasoning is easy to follow.

Hence, your preparation does not differ from the ‘real-deal’ case interview. To prepare for this type of interview, check out our in-depth article on the McKinsey case interview.

Types of Business Problems Discussed

Cases can span a variety of industries and business issues, usually with a creative twist. The scenarios are designed to test a candidate’s ability to apply logical and analytical thinking to real-world business challenges. Do not expect standard cases with cookie-cutter frameworks.

Phone interviews usually involve simpler case studies with less depth than in-person interviews. The complexity of the case might be reduced, focusing on key areas of business judgment rather than detailed analysis.

Unique Challenges of Phone Interviews

Phone interviews come with their own set of challenges, including the absence of visual cues and reliance on verbal communication. Candidates need to be more explicit in their thought process and ensure clear articulation of their ideas. The inability to read the interviewer’s non-verbal cues requires a more structured and proactive approach to communication.

Performance Tips for the Phone Case Interview

Communication and Clarity

Effective communication is crucial in a phone interview, where visual cues are absent. Candidates should focus on speaking clearly and concisely. It’s essential to articulate thoughts in a structured manner, ensuring that the interviewer can easily follow your line of reasoning. Avoid jargon and be explicit in explaining your thought process. Remember, clarity of communication can often outweigh the complexity of your answers.

Structuring Responses

A well-structured response is key to demonstrating logical thinking. Begin by outlining your approach to the problem before diving into the specifics. Use a clear framework to organize your thoughts, whether it’s breaking down the problem into various components or following a step-by-step analytical process. This structure not only helps in maintaining clarity but also showcases your ability to approach problems methodically.

Handling Quantitative and Qualitative Elements

McKinsey interviews often involve both quantitative and qualitative assessments. For quantitative elements, ensure accuracy in your calculations and be comfortable with basic mathematical concepts. Explain your process as you calculate, so the interviewer understands your approach. For qualitative aspects, focus on providing insightful and logical analyses. Draw on your business acumen to offer practical and strategic solutions, and don’t hesitate to think creatively.

Strategy for Making Recommendations

Your final recommendation is a critical component of the case interview. It should be concise, well-reasoned, and supported by the analysis you’ve conducted. Summarize your key findings and explain how they led to your recommendation. It’s important to be decisive yet acknowledge any assumptions or limitations in your analysis. Conclude with confidence, demonstrating that you have thoroughly considered the problem from all angles.

The McKinsey Personal Fit Phone Interview

The second type of phone interview at McKinsey is the personal fit screening, which typically does not delve into the depths of a McKinsey PEI interview (PEI). For a comprehensive understanding of the PEI, readers are encouraged to refer to our detailed article on the McKinsey PEI interview. Like its counterpart, the personal fit screening also spans about 30 minutes.

This segment of the interview process is more straightforward, functioning more as a preliminary screening than a deep evaluative conversation. It focuses on rapid-fire, high-level questions that are distinct in nature from those in the PEI. These questions are designed to gauge a candidate’s overall fit with the firm, their motivations, and their understanding of consulting in general and McKinsey’s work in particular.

Typically, candidates can expect to encounter questions such as:

• “Guide me through your resume” – a prompt that invites candidates to provide a narrative of their professional journey, highlighting key milestones and relevant experiences.
• “Why consulting?” – a question aimed at understanding the candidate’s motivation for choosing the consulting career path.
• “Why McKinsey?” – seeking to uncover the candidate’s reasons for preferring McKinsey over other firms.
• “Are you aware of the work we are doing in [specific practice] and how could you contribute with your experience here?” – particularly relevant for experienced hires, this question assesses the candidate’s knowledge of McKinsey’s sectors or practices and their potential value-add to the firm.

When responding to these questions, candidates should prepare a structured, top-down answer for each, ideally outlining 3-5 key points. This approach should not only succinctly capture the essence of their responses but also strategically link their personal experiences and successes to the skills and competencies sought in consulting. It’s essential to illustrate how one’s background and achievements align with the day-to-day responsibilities and broader objectives of a consultant at McKinsey.

This segment of the interview, while seemingly less intensive than the case interview, is crucial as it offers a window into the candidate’s personality, career aspirations, and alignment with McKinsey’s values and culture.

Setting Up For the Phone Interview

Setting Up a Conducive Environment

To ensure a focused and uninterrupted interview experience, choose a quiet, well-lit room where you are unlikely to be disturbed. The environment should be professional and free from background noise. A neat, uncluttered background is preferable for video interviews. Also, inform others in your vicinity about your interview to avoid unexpected interruptions.

Ensuring Reliable Technology and Connectivity

Before the interview, test your technology. Ensure your phone or computer is fully charged or plugged in. For video interviews, check your internet connection’s stability. A wired connection is preferable to Wi-Fi for its reliability. If using a phone, ensure good network coverage. Conduct a trial run to test the connection and familiarize yourself with the software or platform being used for the interview.

Best Practices for Video and Audio Quality

For video interviews, position your camera at eye level to simulate direct eye contact. Good lighting is crucial; ideally, have a light source in front of you to illuminate your face clearly. Check your audio quality beforehand; using headphones with an in-built microphone can enhance sound clarity and reduce ambient noise. Test the audio to ensure you can hear and be heard without strain.

Post-Interview Process and Next Steps

Timeline for Feedback and Decisions

After the interview, McKinsey typically communicates the outcome within a few days to a week. If there’s a delay, it may be due to the firm considering multiple candidates or internal deliberations. It’s acceptable to follow up if you haven’t heard back within the expected timeframe.

Preparing for Potential Next Rounds

If successful, prepare for more in-depth interviews. These will likely include longer, more complex case studies and deeper discussions on fit and personal experiences. Focus on refining your case-solving techniques and enhancing your ability to articulate your thought process clearly and confidently.

Understanding McKinsey’s Evaluation Methodology

McKinsey’s evaluation is holistic. It considers not only your problem-solving skills but also your ability to communicate effectively, your leadership potential, and how well you align with the firm’s values and culture. Reflecting on feedback, if provided, can be invaluable for understanding areas for improvement, helping you to prepare effectively for subsequent rounds.

Your Pathway to McKinsey: Expert Guidance for Success

As former McKinsey consultants and the highest-rated consulting interview experts, we have specialized in getting our candidates into McKinsey. We can help you by

• tailoring your resume and cover letter to meet McKinsey’s standards
• showing you how to pass the McKinsey Imbellus Solve Game
• showing you how to ace McKinsey interviews and the PEI with our video academy. In this academy, we simulate and debrief real PEI interviews with average and strong performers.
• coaching you in our 1-on-1 sessions to become an excellent case solver and impress with your fit answers (90% success rate after 5 sessions)
• helping you ace your personal fit interview
• preparing your math to be bulletproof for every McKinsey case interview
• helping you structure creative and complex McKinsey cases
• teaching you how to interpret McKinsey charts and exhibits
• providing you with cheat sheets and overviews for 27 industries.

Reach out to us if you have any questions! We are happy to help and offer a tailored program.