Category: Case Interview

Case interview success rate comparison across MBB, Tier-2 consulting firms, and the Big 4.

Case Interview Success Rate by Firm: MBB, Tier-2, and Big 4

Updated July 2026 by Florian Smeritschnig, former McKinsey Senior Consultant. At the case interview stage, roughly 10 to 15% of candidates who reach a McKinsey, BCG, or Bain interview walk away with an offer. Zoom out to everyone who applies, and the overall case interview success rate at MBB falls below 1%. Tier-2 firms and…
Read more

Professional standing at a crossroads between two contrasting paths: one leading to a calm, natural landscape and the other to a congested city, symbolizing the transition from industry to consulting and high-stakes decision-making. Cover for an article on case interview for experienced hires.

Case Interview for Experienced Hires: What’s Different in 2026

By Florian Smeritschnig, former McKinsey Senior Consultant · Updated June 2026 Most experienced hires walk into the case interview assuming their track record will carry them. It won’t. The case interview for experienced hires runs to a higher bar than the entry-level version, with less margin for error and less hand-holding, and it rejects more…
Read more

Cover image for an article on the McKinsey AI Interview, showing a robotic hand reaching toward a network of digital nodes, with the title “The McKinsey AI Interview” and the StrategyCase.com logo.

The McKinsey AI Interview: What It Really Is and How to Prepare

Updated June 2026 · By Florian Smeritschnig, former McKinsey Senior Consultant If you have a McKinsey final round coming up, you have probably seen the headlines. McKinsey is adding an AI interview, and half the internet is telling you to drop everything and learn prompt engineering. That advice is mostly wrong, and following it can…
Read more

Case interview success guide explaining what separates offer holders from other candidates

Case Interview Success: What Separates Offer Holders From Everyone Else

By Florian Smeritschnig, former McKinsey Senior Consultant · Updated July 2026 Case interview success is not decided by how many hours you log or how many cases you grind. It is decided by how you prepare and how you think. Every recruiting season, two candidates put in identical hours, read the same books, and run…
Read more

Candidate struggling in a case interview despite extensive preparation, illustrating why months of case interview prep can still lead to failure. The image is the cover for an article why candidates fail case interviews.

Why Candidates Fail Case Interviews Despite Months of Prep

By Florian Smeritschnig, former McKinsey Senior Consultant. Updated July 2026. Most candidates fail case interviews for one reason: they prepared for the wrong test. Not because they are not smart enough, and not because they did not work hard enough. After five years at McKinsey, where I evaluated candidates, and 2,200+ coaching sessions since, I…
Read more