What are the differences? What are your chances to succeed? We will answer these questions in today’s post.
Internship vs. full-time role and application
The process for full-time or internship roles is very similar. In general, the full application process covers several rounds, starting with the screening stage, followed by two interview rounds that eventually should lead to an offer (read the overview of the consulting application process here).
Normally, the screening stage consists of the same elements for both interns and full-timers. Their application documents are screened and if found suitable, candidates move on to online tests (McKinsey Imbellus, BCG Online Case, BCG Pymetrics, BCG one-way video interview) a phone interview, or directly to the first round of case interviews. In a similar fashion, the first-round case interviews are usually held for all candidates. If you apply for an internship, you will receive the offer or rejection right after this round while full-timers can expect a second round and sometimes even a third-round (after a successful first round, of course). The evaluation criteria for each candidate are the same, however, the benchmark on which they are measured might be slightly lower for potential interns (depending on their stage of development). This is even more true for second-tier or smaller consultancies.
How do your chances differ between an internship and full-time applications?
If you are just interested in an internship, go apply.
If you follow a more long-term perspective and are interested in a full-time role, should you do an internship first? The answer is: That depends.
There are a few benefits of doing an internship before going in full-time. Overall, it is slightly to get in as screening and interview criteria might be more lenient depending on your state of development. Additionally, as an intern, you have the opportunity to get to know the daily work life and the environment within the company before you commit your life to it. On the downside, you have many more opportunities to screw up in a ten-week internship compared to a second round of interviews (read how to survive your first weeks in consulting here). Keep in mind that conversion rates from internship to full-time roles are quite high, as firms tend to give interns a positive experience and in a more ‘relaxed’ working environment in order to attract them for a full-time role. However, sometimes even very good people do not get extended an offer in the end for no apparent reason (e.g. falling through the cracks as the partner is in a bad mood, never available during the project, or simply for some bureaucratic reasons).
If you are unsure about your long-term goals, it is probably best to do an internship first. Even if you don’t get extended an offer, you can still apply for a full-time role later (except when your performance during the internship was really bad), as you would do if you have failed the first-round interviews (read how to recoup from a bad interview here).
Be aware that some elite firms such as McKinsey & Company do not accept internship applications once you have graduated. For some firms, offers extended at the end of an internship are conditional to successfully passing a final partner round consisting of one or more interviews with senior organizational leaders.
Lastly, keep in mind that doing an internship in a lower-tier consultancy can often help to enhance your profile for tier 1 management consulting applications.
In the end, the decision is up to you. Think about what suits you best and apply for the respective position.
How we can help you get the consulting internship or full-time role
If you want to improve your case interview and problem-solving skills and learn the key habits and tricks that make you succeed in any McKinsey, BCG, and Bain interview, try our case practice.
Together, we spent 9 years with McKinsey and coached 100s of candidates to receive their desired offers. Our mock interviews have a 100% satisfaction rate and 9 out of 10 candidates that go through our Consulting interview coaching program receive the offer.
If you want to get the same knowledge in an extensive 40-part video series, check out our Ready-for-McKinsey video academy.
If you need to brush up on your math skills, we have created a program with detailed insider learning materials, 25 videos and a guidebook as well as 2,000 practice drills that mimick the McKinsey, BCG, and Bain case interview math as well as the aptitude and analytics test math for you here: the Case Interview Math Mastery.
We also offer resume and cover letter guides and personal screening, as well as guides and videos on how to pass the McKinsey Problem Solving Game and the BCG Online Case.
Florian spent 5 years with McKinsey as a senior consultant. He is an experienced consulting interviewer and problem-solving coach, having interviewed 100s of candidates in real and mock interviews. He started StrategyCase.com with the goal to make McKinsey more accessible for top-talent, using tailored and up-to-date know-how about its recruiting.